Life Insurance: What's It Worth? (And Who Says?)

Life Insurance: What's It Worth? (And Who Says?)

Pension Protection Act forces appraisers of donated policies to reassess methods, qualifications
News story posted in Intangible Personal Property on 3 September 2008| 9 comments
audience: National Publication | last updated: 18 May 2011


Gifts of life insurance policies to not-for-profit organizations can benefit both the organization and the donor, the latter in the form of an often sizeable income tax charitable deduction. However, under the requirements of the Pension Protection Act of 2006 (PPA),
determining the fair market value of policies requires the help of an appraiser with the appropriate expertise and experience. In this article from the Journal of Accountancy, appraiser Alan Breus, CLU, ChFC reviews current appraisal requirements and appraiser qualifications.

By Alan Breus, CLU, ChFC. Alan Breus is principal of The Breus Group of San Jose, Calif., a qualified member of the Appraisers Association of America and an insurance adviser to Northwestern University. Contact Alan Breus via email or go to

Executive Summary:

Gifts of life insurance policies to not-for-profit organizations can benefit both the organization and the donor, the latter in the form of an often sizeable income tax deduction. However, under the new requirements of the Pension Protection Act of 2006 (PPA),
determining the fair market value of policies will require the help of an appraiser with the appropriate expertise and experience.

Cash-value policies, such as whole life, are valued at fair market value, limited by their cost basis. A paid-up policy is valued at its replacement cost. A policy that is not fully paid up is valued at the lesser of premiums paid or its interpolated terminal reserve amount.

The PPA now requires non-cash charitable contributions to be appraised by a qualified appraiser according to generally accepted appraisal standards. The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), developed by the Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal Foundation, is considered as satisfying this requirement.

A qualified appraiser is one who, among other things, performs appraisals regularly and is qualified by experience, education and other factors to appraise the type of property in question. He or she must have earned an appraisal designation from a recognized professional appraiser organization or meet minimum requirements for education and experience. For returns filed since February 2007, such education includes relevant college or professional-level coursework. Experience must include at least two years of buying, selling or valuing similar property.

In addition, the PPA increased taxpayer penalties for appraisals that cause a tax understatement.

Full Text:

Not everyone can make a multimillion-dollar bequest to his or her alma mater, but many alums have an insurance policy for which they might easily be persuaded to name their school or another not-for-profit organization as owner and beneficiary.

University development offices and other prospective nonprofit beneficiaries are well aware of this, and many encourage gifts of policies. What they and prospective donors might be less sure of—and consequently need your help in deciding—is how to properly value donated life insurance interests for tax purposes. And you may need to brush up on the new provisions for qualified appraisals under the Pension Protection Act of 2006 (PPA).

Qualified appraisals are a concern for taxpayers donating noncash charitable gifts of all kinds. The questions of appraiser qualification and responsibility remain an area of concern for the IRS due to a long history of valuation problems dealing with gifted life insurance. Life insurance can be prone to incorrect valuation because of the plethora of types of policies available, ownership and beneficiary issues and misunderstanding of valuation methods of how to apply fair market valuation principles.

Many CPAs may be more attuned to providing an estimate of the value of business interests and other types of assets rather than those required for life insurance policies. This article, therefore, is intended to help you and your clients navigate this murky minefield and offers suggestions on how to find a qualified appraiser who can complete and sign the revised Form 8283 for charitable donations of life insurance interests.


For donors, gifted life policies can be a source of tax deductions and can help meet estate and personal financial planning objectives. In some cases, these policies also allow for the building of a less costly legacy with worn-out assets that may no longer be needed. More than 70% of life insurance policies, including group and secondary-market policies, lapse for nonpayment because they no longer meet any pressing estate planning or business planning needs. As noted by the Insurance Information Institute (, a per-year lapse ratio of 7.7% (38.5% lapses in five years) is the industry standard, down from 8.75% per year for the period 1995–2000. Additional material suggests the lapse rate is 3% per year for individuals over 65.


Both these superannuated as well as newly written life insurance policies are a great source of new money for not-for-profits. Empirical mortality tables have the uncanny knack of being correct. It’s not a matter of whether the insured is going to die, it’s when, and if the portfolio of policies is sufficiently diversified, we even know what year that might be within a reasonable margin. Regardless of whether the policy is term insurance, some form of cash-value insurance, assignable old group policies or even the senior settlement payouts from the secondary market, life insurance is a viable tool to the planned-giving community.

In general, the deductible amount of a donated life insurance interest is its fair market value, which is the amount an insurance company would charge for a comparable contract. If the policy has a cash surrender value, that amount is considered the fair market value if the donee intends to cash out the policy rather than hold it as an investment. Otherwise, for fully paid-up whole-life polices, fair market value is considered to be replacement cost. A policy that is not fully paid up is typically valued at the lesser of either total premiums paid or the “interpolated terminal reserve,” an amount designated by the insurer to fulfill its obligations under the contract. It is similar to the cash surrender value and is available from the insurer. In any case, however, the value can be no greater than the policy’s cost basis. A term insurance policy’s value is typically the amount of future premiums that would be paid to maintain the policy.

Example. Mr. A. Giver was a partner in a company that was recently sold to a conglomerate. His interest in the partnership was paid out to him, and his $1 million insurance-funded buy/sell agreement was canceled. Giver’s partner transferred the funding policy to him. No transfer-for-value issues arise when a policy is transferred to the original insured—IRC § 101(a)(2). But after careful review, Giver decided he had no real need to continue the coverage. By donating the policy to his alma mater, the University of Higher Aspirations, he can deduct, in the case of a non-paid-up policy, any new premiums he pays and the lesser of the premiums he has paid or the interpolated terminal reserve value, up to the policy’s cost basis.

In the case of a paid-up policy, the deduction is the cost of replacing the coverage with a comparable policy, again, limited by cost basis. If the policy were term insurance, he would have no accumulated cost basis but can deduct all future dollars he donates to the university for it to pay premiums as maintenance. On an immediate basis, Giver’s deduction is limited to his actual cost of purchase, which may or may not be equal to the total cost basis as noted by the insurance company.

Of course, if Giver were medically impaired, he might go to the secondary life insurance market and sell his policy for some new medically underwritten original issue discount dollar value. If the policy is sold, then Giver is holding cash that is taxable partly as ordinary income (amount over basis up to cash value), with the remainder taxed as a capital asset.

If he then donates that cash to the university, he will receive an immediate tax deduction. If he instead takes the cash and contributes it to a charitable remainder trust, he will receive either an immediate income tax deduction for the contribution or a deduction to offset the income he has to recognize within the trust. This might glean substantial dollars for the university and, through the use of a charitable remainder trust, may give our donor substantial deductions against current income, while the donee university in this way receives a rich and unexpected bequest. This scenario, although interesting in concept, is fraught with possible reporting problems, which may end up being placed at the feet of the qualified appraiser.


Historically, misguided valuations and resulting erroneous deductions have been based on the policy’s total death benefit, or the policy cash value or settlement value from the secondary market, without noting how the original cost affects the amount of the deduction. In other cases, policies with revocable beneficiary designations have been accepted by less-sophisticated charitable organizations and been deducted by the donor. And in yet other cases, policies have been attributed to insurance companies that have never existed.

Although there is no specific format for an appraisal of an insurance policy, it is important to address items of information that are required to be in the appraisal as specified in IRS Notice 2006-96. An appraisal will be treated as having been conducted in accordance with generally accepted appraisal standards within the meaning of § 170(f)(11)(E)(i)(II) if, for example, it is consistent with the substance and principles of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, as developed by the Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal Foundation. Additional information is available at In addition, AICPA members may be subject to standards of valuation or calculation engagements under Statement on Standards for Valuation Services no. 1, Valuation of a Business, Business Ownership Interest, Security, or Intangible Asset.

Information is required from the insurance policy itself and the issuing insurance company. This data is found in the insurance policy and includes: all the information found on the specification or summary page, the information found on the policy data page, the information found on the table of premiums page (term insurance) or the table of cash values (ordinary life), the history of ownership and beneficiary designations, with any and all changes and/or transfers and a recitation of rights of conversion and/or exchange found in the body of the policy. The information required from the insurance company is: the owner/donor’s adjusted cost basis, the current policy status (including values) derived from the most current policy statement, or in-force illustration prepared by the insurance company.

A deduction may be disallowed because it was based on the recommendation of an appraiser who wasn’t properly qualified. For the charity, the only negative consequence may be losing a valuable relationship with its benefactor. But someone is going to be at fault for the unhappy donor’s plight.

The solution. Congress perceived a need for more regulation of the appraisal process and qualification of the appraiser, leading to the PPA’s expanded requirements. For a general description of PPA changes, see “Pension Protection Act Changes Valuations for Tax Purposes,” JofA, Sept. 07, page 40. Note especially that a taxpayer must obtain a qualified appraisal before completing Part 1 of Section B of Form 8283 and, for donated property worth more than $5,000, attach the appraiser-prepared summary of that appraisal to the tax return (see “Form 8283” below). Requirements for appraisals are listed in Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-13(c). The PPA expanded these requirements to include that an appraisal must be conducted in accordance with generally accepted appraisal standards.


Treasury Regulation § 1.170A-13(c) (5)(i) defines a qualified appraiser as one who:

Holds himself or herself out to the public as an appraiser and performs appraisals regularly.

Is qualified to make appraisals of the type of property being valued, as determined by the appraiser’s background, experience, education and membership, if any, in a professional appraisal association.

Is independent.

Understands that an intentionally false overstatement of the value of the appraised property may subject the appraiser to civil penalties.

Under IRC § 170(f)(11), appraisers are now required to have earned an appraisal designation from a recognized professional appraiser organization or otherwise meet minimum requirements for education and experience specified by the Secretary. Under transitional terms of Notice 2006-96, for returns filed after Feb. 16, 2007, minimum requirements may be met by having successfully completed college or professional-level coursework relevant to the property being valued, plus two years experience in the trade or business of buying, selling or valuing that type of property. Appraisers must describe this education and experience in the appraisal. They must also prepare their appraisal based on demonstrated competence in valuing the type of property in the appraisal.

Appraisers who meet the requirements may be found through organizations listed in the resources box under “Organizations for finding a qualified appraiser.” Relevant education in life insurance can be attained with the Chartered Life Underwriter, Chartered Financial Consultant or other college-based designation.

FORM 8283

Then a C corporation, partnership, S corporation or individual donates property, including life insurance, and claims a deduction of more than $500, Form 8283, Noncash Charitable Contributions, must be filed, with Section A completed. If the amount is $5,000 for a single item or group of similar items, such as books, to several charitable donees; art valued at $20,000 or more; or property for which a $500,000 deduction is claimed (and if an exception does not apply as stated in the instructions to Form 8283), the donor must obtain a written appraisal and fill out Section B of Form 8283. Section B, Part I, contains information relating to the donated property itself. Part II is the signature declaration by the donor that identifies all donated items that have been appraised at a value of less than $500 each. Part III contains the appraiser’s binding declaration that reflects all of the changes in the PPA, specifically, an acknowledgment that the appraiser may be subject to the gross valuation misstatement penalty of section 6695A.


You, the CPA, are now faced with the task of finding a fully qualified appraiser. Barring that step, you risk daunting penalties, including losing the ability to practice before the IRS for three years while paying a penalty that can be as much as 10% of the tax underpayment or 125% of the fee received for the appraisal, whichever is less. Added to this is the possibility that a disillusioned taxpayer could sue you as well as the unqualified appraiser to pay additional tax, penalties and interest assessed on a deficiency; and there is no longer a reasonable cause exception to a valuation understatement. One way to find a qualified appraiser is to contact an acknowledged appraisal organization for a qualified appraiser in your area.

Copyright 2008 Alan Breus and Journal of Accountancy. Used by permission.

Add comment

Login or register to post comments


Life Insurance Appraisals Easily Available

Any transaction involving a life insurance policy should be done pursuant to an independent third party appraisal, whether or not an IRS rule currently applies in that area. In other words, a transfer in connection with a charity certainly requires an appraisal due to the PPA (and the general fiduciary duty of the trustee of a charity); a transfer in connection with a pension certainly requires an appraisal due to Rev. Proc. 2005-25 (and the general fiduciary duty of the trustee of a retirement plan), unless you rely on PERC. Although there is no comparable IRS mandate in estate tax planning, you would be foolish not to get the same appraisal in connection with estate tax planning.

Value of Life Policy for Estate and Gift Tax Purposes

Hello Bruce. Thanks for you comment. Can you recommend any good appraisers for estate and gift tax purposes? The people who wrote the article only do appraisals for gifts to not for profit organizations. John

Qualify Life Insurance Appraisers

Liz Monty, Veriti Consulting, P.O. Box 10278, Scottsdale, AZ 85271-0278,; 602-229-1280 #204. Best regards.

Gift tax value of life insurance

The gift tax value requires an actuary, why wouldn't you rely on the insurance company's valuation at the time policy ownership is changed? TRX

Requiring An Actuary To Value An Insurance Policy

I do not claim to be an expert in (i) life insurance policies or (ii) actuarial science. I am merely a tax attorney, and my practice covers barely 20% of tax law. So my response is as follows: the value of an insurance policy (this is from memory) is what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, neither being under compulsion to buy or sell, and both being in possession of all of the relevant facts. Were I buying an insurance policy I would have an experienced insurance agent obtain the medical records, get a HIPAA release, have the medical records reviewed by an expert and get a life expectancy study. I believe those studies can be acquired for about $500. So, yes, were the transaction large enough to warrant it, I would have the client go through all of those steps. When you hire a firm like Veriti Consulting. they value the policy with the caveat that the insured's health is unchanged from when the policy was issued so that a normal life expectancy still applies. In response to your question, I wouldn't rely on the insurance company's valuation at the time policy ownership is changed because the carrier's "valuation" isn't an appraisal. I hope that makes sense. But I am interested in the comments of anyone else. I do not claim to have the revealed truth. Thanks. Best regards.

Life Insurance Appraisala

In appraising a life-insurance policy, unusual life-expectancy circumstances must sometimes be taken into consideration. For example. I am working on a case right now where one person is beneficiary of a policy insuring another person for $650,000. The cash value of the policy is $65,000. The insured has only a few months to live. For business reasons the beneficiary may need to transfer that policy to another person. The fair-market value of that death benefit must surely be deemed to be more than $65,000 because the policy is expected to mature as a death benefit in the very near future. The true value is very close to $650,000, i.e., the preset value of the expected payment of $650,000.

Insurance Appraisals

I think the rules are quite clear that insurance is a hard to value asset requiring an appraisal. Insurance values are more than cash value, cash surrender value, interpolated terminal reserve, etc., especially with the secondary market for existing contracts. Whether or not you believe a donor's policy should be sold is another matter, but the fact that there is a market and the IRS values the willing buyer - willing seller as a way to peg a value for a donated asset is an important consideration. Since appraisers can't be a party to the transaction, I think that rules out the insurance carrier and its form 712, the agent who sold the policy or the agent likely to resell the policy for the donee as likely appraisers. Vaughn W. Henry

Life insurance appraisals

Life insurance gifts have required an appraisal for many decades, if an existsing policy was contributed to charity, because it is a non-cash gift subject to the need of a Form 8283, etc. The question has been - who is the qualified appraiser for life insurance policies? Even the new requriement don't quite fit. The chosen insurance professional that is to be the appraiser must document his/her expertise and meet the revised requirements as much as possible.

Considering all of the pages

Considering all of the pages of information regarding the implications of the PPA up to this point; this is the first indication I have seen of life insurance contracts being viewed in this way. It has always been my understanding that the amount available for a deduction on a donated whole, universal or VUL life insurance contract in almost every instance is the total value of premiums paid in to the contract. The need to have this number verified with "an appraisal" will unfortunately have a chilling effect on future gifts of this kind.

Group details



This group offers an RSS feed.
7520 Rates:  July 3.4%  June 3.4%  May 3.2%

Already a member?

Learn, Share, Gain Insight, Connect, Advance

Join Today For Free!

Join the PGDC community and…

  • Learn through thousands of pages of content, newsletters and forums
  • Share by commenting on and rating content, answering questions in the forums, and writing
  • Gain insight into other disciplines in the field
  • Connect – Interact – Grow
  • Opt-in to Include your profile in our searchable national directory. By default, your identity is protected

…Market yourself to a growing industry